Fleet World Workshop Tools
Car Tax Calculator
CO2 Calculator
Car Comparator
Van Tax Calculator
EV Car Comparator
BiK Rates Company Car Tax

Inaugural Fleet World WLTP Challenge brings real-world insight into fuel economy and smarter driving skills

Results are now in from the first-ever Fleet World WLTP Challenge, which shows how the new WLTP cycle is reflective of real-world driving economy – and can even be exceeded with the use of everyday smarter driving techniques.

Fleet World‘s 2019 WLTP Challenge saw more than 20 vehicles drive a 220-mile route to check their real-world fuel consumption against official WLTP figures

The latest evolution of the long-standing MPG Marathon, the WLTP Challenge one-day economy driving event saw more than 20 vehicles drive a 220-mile route from Bristol to the Midlands and back, including various waypoints and time restrictions, designed to simulate a typical journey for an employee driving on company business.

Held in association with event partners ALD Automotive, IAM RoadSmart, RAC, Airmax Remote, Chevin Fleet Solutions and Vehicle Livery Solutions, the event showed that 90% of the vehicles tested – which included petrol, diesel, hybrid, electric and hydrogen technology – exceeded their official published WLTP fuel economy figures.

As a result, the event highlights that consumers can have full confidence in the official published fuel economy figures for new vehicles in the UK.

Stand-out performances include the vehicle attaining the lowest fuel consumption on the day – Vauxhall’s Astra 1.5 diesel – which posted 84.99mpg (a 40% improvement on the official WLTP figure) with experienced driver Andrew Duerden at the wheel. Meanwhile Honda’s CR-V achieved an incredible 70mpg from its 2.0-litre petrol hybrid engine (70% improvement) at the hands of expert economy driver Fergal McGrath; and SEAT’s new fleet-favourite Tarraco, driven by fleet manager and self-confessed efficient driver Richard Morcom, managed to eke out over 51 miles for every gallon of petrol (a 39% improvement).

For commercial vehicles, Mitsubishi’s L200 Barbarian posted a remarkable 62% uplift compared to the official WLTP figure, while event partner RAC’s patrol van – piloted by Patrol of the Year Ben Aldous – exceeded its official figure, despite carrying all the equipment needed for its everyday roadside assistance duties.

The event also showed the value of driver training. Event partner IAM RoadSmart provided eco training to Fleet World’s Jonathan Musk and Hayley Everett, and also to two of ALD Automotive’s customer service team – Barry Jones and Neil Hobbs. Jonathan actually received eco-driver training from IAM RoadSmart 12 months ago and his 68.8mpg result in the latest RDE2-compliant Jaguar XE at the WLTP Challenge (a 42% improvement), shows the long-term value in driver training for any organisation.

Meanwhile, Hayley, who had never received any formal driver training until shortly before the event, achieved 73.32mpg at the wheel of the Suzuki Swift (a 43% improvement), which again shows the benefits of the IAM RoadSmart smarter driving techniques as well as the inherent fuel efficiency of the vehicle.

Likewise, Neil and Barry of ALD Automotive had no previous training and, together, managed to beat the official WLTP figure on the Hyundai Ioniq Hybrid by 6%, on a vehicle that is arguably more suited to shorter, more urban journeys – much like the plug-in hybrids on the event.

As highlighted by the BBC News coverage, what these results show is that it’s not only the vehicle that you drive but the way that you drive that affects fuel consumption. Experienced eco-drivers are capable of achieving fantastic fuel economy from any vehicle but smarter driving techniques can be applied by any driver, at any time. Employing greater anticipation, avoiding harsh acceleration and braking, and maintaining vehicle momentum are all key to increasing mpg.

The event also highlighted how electric vehicles are the future for fleets. All three pure electric vehicles (EVs) – Audi e-tron, Nissan Leaf and Tesla’s new Model 3 – were able to complete the same route and timing schedule as their petrol, diesel and hydrogen counterparts, and each of them did so whilst beating their official published efficiency figures (measured in miles per Kilowatt hour or miles/kWh).

To put this into context, in a direct comparison with diesel and petrol-powered vehicles, the cost of a Nissan Leaf completing a 220-mile journey would be £10, whereas a diesel vehicle averaging 70mpg and completing the same journey would cost £19, rising to £25 for a petrol vehicle averaging 50mpg. These figures show as battery technology develops and ranges get longer, electric vehicles’ viability and cost-efficiency for fleets and private motorists will increase too.

WLTP Challenge 2019 organiser, Luke Wikner commented: “The WLTP Challenge 2019 just goes to show that every driver, be they a private motorist or a company car driver behind the wheel of any vehicle, can make significant incremental improvements to their fuel economy. Smarter driving in this way ultimately leads to safer driving, lower fuel bills, lower insurance, lower stress levels for drivers and fleet operators and a happier mobile workforce.

“The Challenge also underlines that the new WLTP test procedure is already proving its worth. Gone are the days when motorists can say that they will never achieve their vehicles’ official fuel consumption figures, as the latest official WLTP figures will be representative of most drivers’ real-world fuel economy, most of the time.”

For the full  list of WLTP Challenge results, click here.

BBC News reported on the WLTP Challenge 2019 throughout the day – see the coverage below (from 5:30mins onwards)
https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0009gkf/points-west-evening-news-14102019

For more details on the Fleet World WLTP Challenge, phone 01727 739160.

For more of the latest industry news, click here.

Natalie Middleton

Natalie has worked as a fleet journalist for 16 years, previously as assistant editor on the former Company Car magazine before joining Fleet World in 2006. Prior to this, she worked on a range of B2B titles, including Insurance Age and Insurance Day. As Business Editor, Natalie ensures the group websites and newsletters are updated with the latest news.

2 Comments

  • Honest John16. Oct, 2019

    Based on the results of the PHEVs should the WLTP for them be revised? And please do not keep on about how economical electric cars are. If you applied the same tax rate as petrol or diesel have put on them, electric cars would be more expensive to run per mile. As soon as we cross a tipping point expect the government to add some sort of levy.

    • Jonathan Musk24. Oct, 2019

      It really depends on whether a 220-mile journey is what you consider as average use for a PHEV. While what you suggest about tax is correct with regards to electric cars, that is not the case today and therefore the economy of electric vehicles mentioned is correct. If the tax situation changes on electricity used as a fuel, this will, of course, change the outcome. It’s worth noting that business electricity incurs non-reclaimable VAT at 20% (if the business uses more than 33 units/day), whereas domestic electricity is 5%.