Driving when sad or agitated increases crash risk nearly tenfold, finds new study

Carried out by the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute in the US and reported in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the study found that drivers also more than double their crash risk when they engage in distracting activities, such as using a handheld cell phone, reading or writing, or using touchscreen menus on a vehicle instrument panel.

The institute’s research also found that drivers engage in some type of distracting activity more than 50% of the time they are driving.

The researchers used results from the Second Strategic Highway Research Program Naturalistic Driving Study, the largest light-vehicle naturalistic driving study ever conducted with more than 3,500 participants across six data collection sites in the United States.. The results are said to provide the most conclusive findings to date of the biggest risks faced by drivers today.

The research found that driver-related factors that include fatigue, error, impairment, and distraction were present in nearly 90% of the crashes.

“We have known for years that driver-related factors exist in a high percentage of crashes, but this is the first time we have been able to definitively determine – using high-severity, crash-only events that total more than 900–the extent to which such factors do contribute to crashes,” said Tom Dingus, lead author of the study and director of the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute.

Travelling well above the speed limit creates about 13 times the risk, and driver performance errors such as sudden or improper braking or being unfamiliar with a vehicle or roadway have an impact on individual risk.

Yet factors previously thought to increase driver risk, such as applying makeup or following a vehicle too closely, were only minimally present or were not present at all in the crashes analysed.

Commenting on the research, RAC spokesman Simon Williams said: “The fact this was a long-term study using video to observe drivers’ behaviour at the wheel makes it particularly significant and its findings therefore need to be heeded as they show just how prevalent distractions in accidents are.

“We know being distracted at the wheel can have tragic consequences but, based on this research, UK Government statistics around contributory factors in accidents seem to dramatically downplay the effect of distractions as they report that only 4% of road deaths in 2014 were attributable to them.

“All it takes is a moment’s loss of concentration from reaching for a mobile phone, fiddling with a sat nav or adjusting an in-vehicle device to lose control and find yourself involved in a life-changing accident.

“The latest RAC Report on Motoring shows the dangers posed by other motorists using their hand-held mobile phones to talk, text or go online are a growing worry for many drivers with more than a third (34%) saying this is one of their top four areas of concern. There is still a surprising number of motorists (12%) who think that it is acceptable to take a short call with a hand-held mobile phone while driving, despite this being illegal since December 2003.”

For more of the latest industry news, click here.

Natalie Middleton

Natalie has worked as a fleet journalist for over 20 years, previously as assistant editor on the former Company Car magazine before joining Fleet World in 2006. Prior to this, she worked on a range of B2B titles, including Insurance Age and Insurance Day.